Kate Gauger describes her role at Napa Valley Unified School District as a dream job. She oversees the full arc of teacher development—from brand-new teachers entering the profession through veteran educators in their late careers. When she stepped into this newly created position three years ago, she knew evaluation would be critical to supporting teachers at every stage. What she didn't know was that the digital platform her district used would become the biggest obstacle to building the system she envisioned.

‍

When Evaluation Lives in a File Drawer

Before KickUp, Napa Valley used a legacy system that Kate describes with a vivid metaphor: a file drawer. You open it up, take out a folder, do a little work in it, put it back, and shut the drawer. That's where it lives. That's where it stays.

The platform digitized what could have been done on paper, but it offered no pathway beyond compliance. When Kate tried to extract insights from evaluation data or customize the platform for Napa Valley's needs, she hit walls. Support tickets disappeared without follow-through. Questions went unanswered for days. The platform treated educator development as a footnote.

Most critically, the system reinforced the exact mindset Kate was trying to shift: that evaluation was a box to check rather than an opportunity for genuine growth. If it's valuable, you don't put it in a drawer and forget about it. You keep it somewhere and return to it, or it has an impact that lasts beyond the evaluation.

‍

A Platform Built for What Teachers Do

When Kate began exploring alternatives to their legacy system and discovered KickUp, something fundamental clicked. It opened up her entire understanding of what it means to create a system for teacher support.

The difference wasn't just features—it was how the components worked together. Evaluation data could drive professional learning. Professional learning created a need to see new practices in action through classroom observations. Those observations fed back into evaluation, creating a continuous cycle of growth.

Three elements stood out:

• Partnership over transactions. KickUp's team included former educators who understood the work. Kate's dedicated customer success manager became a genuine partner, consistently offering to find solutions, explore new features, and iterate on what the district needed. The company was evolving in line with its customer base—responding to where the action was.
• Ownership of the tool. Kate could make changes herself without calling IT or submitting requests to a programmer. The platform was intuitive enough that she could configure workflows, update rosters, and manage processes on her own timeline—and principals reported the same ease of use.
• Built for educator development, not HR administration. Unlike enterprise systems where evaluation is a small piece of a much larger suite, KickUp focuses entirely on instructional leadership. That specificity matters when you need to customize workflows, extract meaningful data, or build processes that reflect how teachers grow.

‍

Shifting from Accountability to Ownership

Kate isn't just implementing a new tool—she's reshaping how Napa Valley thinks about evaluation. 

She uses a medical analogy to describe what she's building toward: It's like hearing a diagnosis from a doctor. You could say, 'Oh well, I'll just keep living my life.' Or you could say, 'That's my diagnosis—maybe I should walk 20 minutes a day. Maybe I should tend to that somehow.' And then talk about it in a year's time after working on it.

That shift from accountability to ownership is the goal. When teachers own their growth—when they get the diagnosis and work on it whether they're being evaluated or not—the entire dynamic changes.

KickUp makes that vision tangible. Once evaluations are complete, Kate plans to offer six-week professional learning courses tied directly to evaluation data. Teachers will choose their own courses based on the areas they want to develop. That is ownership. That is exciting—someone being able to do that rather than being told what to attend.

‍

Building the Complete System

Napa Valley is just beginning to tap into what KickUp can do. The next frontier is the data. With more consistent evaluations this year, Kate will have meaningful insights about what teachers need. She's building her skills in dashboards and reporting so she can extract trends and design targeted support. She's also piloting KickUp's coaching module next year to bring mentorship into the system.

And her role is expanding. The district is writing to the state to become accredited for teacher induction, which means Kate will oversee the full continuum of teacher development—from induction through late career.

‍

Why It Matters

For districts using enterprise HR platforms that treat evaluation as an afterthought, Kate's story offers a clear alternative. The shift to KickUp wasn't about one killer feature or a flashy interface—it was about finding a partner who understands that evaluation, professional learning, and classroom observations need to work together as a system.

The implementation itself reinforced that difference. Principals found the platform intuitive and were able to navigate evaluations without constant support requests. Kate has since conducted three principal workshops focused on evaluation—moving quickly beyond technical  training to deeper conversations about mindset, values, and the time leaders invest in classrooms.

For Kate, the win isn't just operational efficiency or better data—it's the opportunity to build a culture where teachers own their growth, where evaluation drives meaningful learning, and where the platform supports rather than obstructs that vision.

‍